Pages

Sunday, January 5, 2014

Collection Noir Liquid Black Liner: A Review


This was a purchase that I did no prior research on before purchasing it. I had just run out of foundation, concealer, and liquid liner all at the same time. It was a travesty right? So I went out to Ulta and had faith in my judgement of picking out some products that could work for me. In doing so, I picked up the NYX Collection Noir Liquid Black Liner.
You can create thin lines or thick lines easily.

The control I have with this thing is simply amazing. I can't get enough of it. The applicator is a fine, thin, long flexible brush. This is the real beauty of it, it's flexible when you need it to be and just the right amount of stiffness. I hope that makes sense, but if you use liquid liner as much as I do, I think you'll get the idea. 

In the past, I've used Revlon's Color Stay liquid Liner and I honestly think that the formulation and applicator wasn't of the quality of this liner. I always managed to apply the liner too generously with the applicator and the formulation melted off my eyes as I have quite oily lids. Yet, when I actually wanted to take of the eyeliner it seemed to just stick around. I've also used a ELF, and other various brands I can't recall well enough to have any input.  Anyways back to the NYX liner! 

The formulation of this liner is awesome, it doesn't budge. Not after an 2 hours, not after 3, not until you want it to come off. That is how liner should always be. Now, since I have oily lids, that's saying a lot. Usually liner will transfer on my lids or it will just deteriorate in some places, but not with this one. This is the longest lasting eyeliner I have tried besides my Bobbi Brown Gel Liner. However I usually expect gel liners to be more long lasting since they're thicker. 

I can see a potential problem for some of you might be that it's difficult for you to take off. I kind of think that with liners you have to pick the lesser of two evils. I would rather have a little more difficulty taking off my liner, than having difficulty keeping it on. On another note, I use Argan Oil to take of my eye makeup and it makes things much easier. 

The one gripe I have with this liner, is that it has a bit of satin finish. At least, that's the finish I've experienced. I personally prefer a matte black line, but to each his own. If you don't mind that or actually prefer shiner liner than you'll be fine with this. 

The last great perk of this liner? It's runs for $5.99 at Ulta. I'll wait for the applause to die down.... 
In my opinion if a product is great AND the price is, you literally cannot ask for anything better. Except for maybe a liner that could do your work for you or something, but we'll just have to wait for science to catch up with my ideas. 

All in all, the best drugstore liner I've bought thus far, besides the finish. 

I would recommend this liner to you if:

  • you have trouble with oily lids, or liner that moves around. 
  • you are someone who is still learning or perfecting their cat eye technique as it's very easy to use and control where you're putting the product and how much you're using. 

I do not recommend this liner to you if:

  • you like your makeup off to come off in a swipe.
  • If you dislike the look of a satin or shinier finish like me, you might want to skip this one.

As for me repurchasing it, i'm on the fence. I love everything about it besides that shiny finish. I might read up and research the rest of the liner in NYX's Collection Noir and perhaps there is a similar formulation without the shine. If anyone has any recommendations I would love to hear them. 
XOXO

No comments:

Post a Comment